How do I submit a claim?

During Normal Business Hours, please contact Anthony Insurance and one of our agents will be happy to assist you through the claim process.

Emergency Claims Service after Business Hours:

  • Erie Insurance Group Policyholders may call Erie directly at 800-367-3743.
  • Travelers Policyholders may call 800-238-6225 or submit the claim online.
  • Progressive Policyholders may call 800-Progressive or submit the claim online, 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.
  • Farmers Mutual Fire Policyholders may call 800-545-7806.
  • Millville Mutual Policyholders may call 800-262-8495 and press 1 for Claims.
  • Foremost Policyholders may call 800-527-3907 or submit the claim online.
  • Aegis Policyholders may call 800-233-2160 or submit a claim online.